To the Russian/Ukrainian/Slavic Christians living in the Puget Sound, the Washington State Criminal Justice Center in Burien is a very familiar facility. Over the years, the facility had been rented by numerous churches and para-organizations for events. What most Slavics didn’t know is the sad history of that facility.
I believe the facility’s history can teach us all some valuable lessons.
Community Chapel and Bible Training Center was an independent, “oneness Pentecostal” church started in 1967 by Pastor Donald Lee Barnett. It started in his home, and continued to grow to over 3,000 people with a Bible school, and over 150 active ministries. Within time, they purchased 36 acres, constructed a chapel, an elementary school, a printing press, a recording studio, a Bible school, and other facilities. But with time, everything fell apart and was boarded up, and eventually sold. The facility became what we know it today as the Washington State Criminal Justice Center in Burien.
What happened? Why did it fall apart?
The Rev. David Wilkerson referred to what happened at Community Chapel as “the most grievous thing I’ve ever heard in my 30 years of ministry, and the worst error that’s ever come into the charismatic movement.”
Here is some info of what began to take place, from Wikipedia, and other sources. Please note, this content is for a mature audience only:
In 1983, Barnett told his congregation that he was taken “in Spirit” to heaven, where he sang with angels and experienced “oneness of being” with Christ. Following this, he instituted “dancing before the Lord,” which was a free-form, individual dance with spiritual implications. In 1985, however, this evolved into a highly controversial, intimate two-person dancing practice known as “spiritual connections.”
During church services, members were instructed to find a dance partner, known as a “connection.” By staring into each other’s eyes, a process known as connecting, partners were told they would in actuality be seeing Jesus in each other’s eyes, and were encouraged to look with love into their spiritual connection’s eyes in order to express their love to Jesus. Throughout the week, both in and out of church, members were encouraged to spend time with their spiritual connections in a kind of “quasi-dating relationship.” Physical intimacy often accompanied these “spiritual” connections, and connection love was taught to be more intense, and more desirable, than marital love. A former member has stated that the connecting experience was so intense that she and other women would experience orgasms without ever having any physical contact with their connections.
It was taught that God was using the “spiritual connections” to break down the barriers and inhibitions within the congregation, and promote greater “unity” within the church. Spouses that felt jealousy watching were taught to “release their mates unto the Lord,” and Pastor Barnett taught from the pulpit that members were not to view the connections “carnally.” According to Barnett, what the people were doing (which included hugging, holding, fondling, kissing) was not to be viewed with the eyes of the “flesh.” As he explained, “What’s happening is they’re having spiritual union … It just looks the same on the outside, but what’s really occurring is spiritual, so don’t judge them or their motives.” In the book Churches That Abuse, a former member described what it was like at church services that included such sessions of dancing:
Picture your typical forty-year-old wife who’s out of shape and has six children. There she is watching her husband dancing with this little twenty, year-old , long blonde hair, in his arms, gazing at her for hours. And meanwhile the wife is going insane.
The practice often led to marital friction. The members were told that intimate spiritual experiences with their “spiritual connection” (typically a member of the opposite sex to whom one was not married) could help defeat the “demons of jealousy” and open up the person to a deepened experience of the love of Christ. Critics have attributed spiritual connections to “scores of divorces and separations as well as suicides and the murder of a young girl by her mother.” The practice of spiritual dancing has been highly criticized in newspapers and books, and by former members and researchers.
More on the “Spiritual Connections” from a different source:
Connections originated as a practice, not as the discovery of a doctrine contained in the revelation given to us in the Scriptures (which is the only true kind of revelation). Others with more knowledge about the following events may correct me, and I would invite that, but my understanding is that connections first were practiced in the Kansas satellite church of the Chapel in early 1985 during the move of God we (at first) called “dancing in the spirit”. That move had started in the fall of 1983 at a retreat for the teachers of the Community Chapel Christian school (at which I happened to be present, by the way, because my wife was a teacher there). At first the “move” of dancing was limited to solo dancing, except perhaps for occasional times of dancing in a circle around someone who was being “ministered to.” The aisles and front areas of the Chapel sanctuary filled with people during and after every service with many people dancing individually. Soon couples found themselves dancing together, “worshipping God.”
Then, ironically, in a little outreach church out on the dusty plains of Kansas the exotic hothouse shoot of connections poked through the soil: the eyes of a man and a woman who were “worshipping” (i.e., dancing) together met, and they each felt that a powerful spiritual bond had formed between them and that previously unmet needs were being met in a deep way, maybe even that they were each seeing Jesus in the eyes of the other. Soon this shoot was transplanted to the moister soil of the Seattle church and it began to be formally taught that this was a new way in which Jesus was visiting his church and perfecting love in it. It also began to be taught that we needed to get rid of “legalistic” ideas about marriage so that our spouses would be free to take part in this “move,” because of course, connections were seldom between husband and wife. It was taught that too many hurts had been built up over the years of a marriage for this to be possible. Instead, we must have these hurts healed in a connection, and then return to the marriage to make it even stronger with the love we had received in the connection.
And all along this was supported much more by prophecies, and by tongues and interpretations much more than it was by the teaching of the Scriptures.
There are many other things that happened at the church, between board members and the pastor, and Ive only scratched the surface. Many other questionable teachings were also taught and enforced. Celebrating Christmas and Easter was discouraged because Barnett considered them secular holidays. Engagements could not be announced until Barbara, the pastor’s wife, was informed. Every indication of a negative or “rebellious” attitude or unapproved opinion was attributed to demons.
The ending was sad. The church fell apart. Most of Community Chapel’s congregation had scattered, some seeking refuge in their homes, in new churches, or in their resolve not to be duped again. They are battered emotionally and spiritually. They find it difficult to trust others, to submit to leaders, to expose themselves to the world as people who once supported Community Chapel.
Books, magazine articles, newspaper articles and television reports covered the church’s fall for a long time.
Here are some lessons for us today, as we look back at what was Community Chapel and Bible Training Center.
- Our foundation is the Word of God, not prophecies, and tongues and their interpretations. The “Spiritual connections” which led to many divorces and hurt families is totally not in the word of God, but was supported by prophecies, strange visions, and therefore, blindly believed by many.One of the former members of that church stated, “He (the pastor) gradually diminished and de-emphasized the Bible as something to preach from, as something to live by. He had to get rid of the Book.” When we want to bring in something new and we must de-emphasize the Bible to do so, we must stop ourselves.
- If someone is using fear or manipulation to control you or to get you to do something, stop. Leave. Many members of Community Chapel reflect back and say, “We didn’t want to be left out of ‘the bride,’ left out of the ‘rapture,’ not be part of the ‘man-child ministry.'” Barnett used the fear along with heavy doses of guilt and emotional manipulation to control the congregation. “Everyone was ready to go for anything that seemed spiritual.”
- The tragedy of Community Chapel goes back to a misplaced loyalty. People, thinking that they were placing their allegiance in the Word of God, were actually placing their allegiance in a man and his interpretation of the Word of God. That is crucial to understanding why people were so easily deceived. They thought that they were really obeying the Word of God.
- If you think your church is unique, the best, and the only true church, there is something wrong. The body of Christ is much bigger than our view, our friends, and our interpretations. The true body of Christ exists all over the world. If we can accept that fact, then we can learn from others and be corrected by others. Actually, we must SEEK out advise, correction from others. If Pastor Don Barnett would have an open heart and mind to be accountable and be corrected, all the strange revelations in the 1980’s would have been brought to light and corrected.
Here are some additional Newspaper articles, about the church:
- “The Pastor who sets them dancing” Seattle Post-Intelligencer, April 10, 1986.
- “Minister’s Teachings Wrack Church – ‘Move of God’ Linked to Divorces, Suicides, Alleged Murder of Child” Seattle Times, April 11, 1986.
- “Burien Pastor’s Doctrine is Deplored – ‘Most Grievous Thing,’ Says Charismatic”. Seattle Times, May 3, 1986.
- Lindsey, Robert, “Isolated, Strongly Led Sects Growing in US”, The New York Times, June 22, 1986.
- “Pastor Rebuked for ‘Sexual Sin'” Seattle Times, March 1, 1988
- “‘Embarrassment’ Burien-Church Officials React to Pastor’s Ouster” Seattle Times, March 6, 1988
- “A servant of God or a ‘sick man’?’ Seattle Post-Intelligencer, March 7, 1988.
- “Pastor Plans Court Challenge of Ouster – If that Fails, Barnett says He’ll Start a New Church” Seattle Times, March 7, 1988.
- “Pastor Reinstated for now at Chapel” Seattle Times, March 11, 1988.
- “Pastor Plans to Fire Staff, says Chapel Spokesman”. Seattle Times, March 14, 1988.
- “Church Heading Back to Court – No Firings Yet in Divided Community Chapel”. Seattle Times, March 14, 1988.
- “Burien Pastor Object of Civil Suit as well – Former Church Cites Stress, Unusual Loan”. Seattle Times, March 15, 1988.
- “Senior Elder Quits Posts with Church” Seattle Times, March 16, 1988.
- “Three Chapel Satellites Also Under Fire” Seattle Times, March 17, 1988.
- “Restraining Order Modified”. Seattle Times, March 18, 1988.
- “Barnett Troubles Obscure Success – Friends and Critics Blame his Woes on Ego, Eccentricities” Seattle Times, March 18, 1988.
- “Community Chapel Elders Seek to Dissolve Church”. Seattle Times, March 23, 1988
- “Barnett Loses Bid to Escape Lawsuit-Chapel Elders to Detail Their Sex Lives”. Seattle Times, April 19, 1988.
- “Elder Quits Chapel Post in ‘Connections’ Dispute” Seattle Times, April 27, 1988.
- “Community Chapel (faltering on religious fringe)” Valley Daily News, May 8, 1988.
- “Chapel service reveals strengths, weaknesses of troubled church” Valley Daily News, May 8, 1988
- “Disconnecting from a Church – Battered Christians search for life after Barnett”. Valley Daily News, May 9, 1988.
- “Embattled pastor didn’t admit ’75 guilty plea, records show” Seattle Times, August 11, 1988.
Here are 2 of the sources I used for above article:
13 thoughts on “From a church of 3,000 to 0.”
We lost everything we had when we joined a chapter of this church in the Philippines..I was a 5 years old when my family moved to join the community. My parents were called “rebellious” when they opposed the spiritual connection practice and they nearly separated. I felt so traumatized that these people who called themselves Christians treated my family so badly…and also others who expressed disapproval in the practice…
As a child I knew something was wrong…but all I could do is observe…
It’s a very long story..
Sorry to hear that. My sister was in the church, and it broke her. She later died of an overdose.
As a child brought up in community chapel, later church of agape, I’m now researching the cult I was once a part of at such an impressionable age and I’m disgusted… Out right let down by those I thought protected us as young adults… I never thought to research it much because I left a long time ago… Now I’m just pissed!
I visited the Chapel, twice, once in January, 1984, after seeing some of them in a choir performance at Bellevue Square, the other in Summer, 1986, or 1987, at the peak of the connection movement. The second time, was merely to observe if the rumors were true.
I also attended both the pre auction, and the actual auction, again, merely to observe.
I even passed by Don, in the walkway, outside once, and could easily discern his character.
For months, the utter debacle, was front page news, every day, on all Seattle newspapers.
The entire melee, has got to be, the most heinous and sordid, in all of Christendom, or of churchianity.
Behind the stage, in 1984, I saw people ostensibly in prayer or deliverance, and it was completely wrong and demonic.
The absurdity of the pulpit having warning lights to visiting speakers, and a message, such as ” you have no unction, please sit down”, adds to the shame.
At the auction, the amount of opulence, in terms of items, was staggering, as was the frenzy of visiting churchmen, with deep pockets, buying everything in sight.
Lots of ten or more, Selectric 2 typewriters, were auctioned at $250 per typewriter. ($750 in 2016 dollars)
The breach of doctrine, love, truth, and decency, permeated the Seattle area for many years, and has greatly been a large part of the reason, why the secular community, has shunned any possible desire to know Jesus.
Further, it is appalling, as to the lack of accountability. Other churches, or ministries, could have easily stepped in, even in the 1970s, and discretely closed the Chapel down.
May God help us, to follow Him alone.
Has my comment been published?
Very succinct and accurate description of what took place. I know….I survived it. My husband and myself were disfellowshipped for dissenting and not participating in the debacle.
I recently visited the former community chapel that is now called Church of Agape located in Renton, Washington with my relative. I’ve been many times growing up but it was different going as a conscious adult. They have a sign that only permits members and unfriendly greeters who do not greet you but just make sure you are not a news reporter at the door. Hal Price is the new pastor. My relative told me he married his now wife Cyndi Price when he was counseling Her and Her then husband back in the days of community chapel. According to my relative who grew up in Commuinty Chapel the now new pastor Hal Price had a spiritual connection with his now wife Cyndi who was married at the time. She said that Hal was counseling her and her then husband when the affair took place. I was deeply disturbed to see that the main focus was still spiritual connections. The majority of the service was dancing between men and women. I was saddened to see so much inspropriate touching. it felt like a perverted orgy rather then a house of God. Donald Barnett sat in the side of the front row and looked very sickly. There was only one young family and their three kids. I saw no other children. The women were all in skirts. I swear if I had the names of most of the single men there they would be registered sex offenders. I am still disgusted and haunted at what I recently viewed. My relative said Donald and Hal Price still kick people out of the church, still control and she said most people think of Hal Price as a god. What confuses me is why my relative still attends! She recognizes the sin yet keeps going. Church of Agape is a cult lead by cult leaders.
Jude 1:4 “For certain men have crept in among you unnoticed — ungodly ones who were designated long ago for condemnation. They turn the grace of our God into a license for immorality, and they deny our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ. “
Sept 16 2016 Friday.
Last night I dreamed I was in a new church and wanted to praise the lord in the dance but no one was doing that so I restrained myself. Then I thought that if I went in a corner or something where no one saw me that I could praise the Lord in the dance there. So I went into their auditorium and praised the Lord in the dance and danced with a small oriental fella and I got in the spirit and hugged him. Some guy walking by said something to the effect that I shouldn’t be praising the Lord in the dance, and I told him the bible said to do it. Then I realized I was in church of agape. And went to church service, and there was only 4 of us all sitting up front, Don Barnett began preaching and I realized that it was Saturday and not Sunday. Don’s sermon was another one of those highly unmemorable ones that I could not concentrate on at all, totally without any anointing. So as I was leaving I asked this guy if church of agape danced anymore and he said no, that you could only dance if it would cause someone to cry. I said is that building over there where they go to dance and he said no it’s where you go to cry, and of course only women go there cause they are the only ones who cry,. Then I said to him that there was therefore no reason to go to church of agape if one couldn’t praise the lOrd in the dance. I asked him if he knew that church of agape had been in self destruct mode for years. And he started making loud noises and ran away so he couldn’t hear me. He turned into a squirrel hiding behind a tree to avoid me. So I picked up my gear to ride off in my motorcycle thinking that maybe I could find a church where I could praise the lord in the dance in some corner where it wouldn’t been seen cause I knew that praising the Lord in the dance offends Christians tremendously.
I’m so angry and disgusted recording this dream I wanna puke.
Footnote: Last Sunday I praised God in the dance, and bowed down to him at praise time wathching Jimmy Swaggart on TV with my wife and we connected in the spirit and blew agape kisses at one another. It was that same exhilarating experience I had at COA and CCBTC. So God is making a way for me to get back into that deep deep caught away in the spirit experience.
Recent News: Church of Agape is no longer called Church of Agape. Donald Price was forced into a home. Hal (Harold) Price took over and just got out of a huge legal battle because he stole most of Don Barnett’s money and all of the Church of Agape’s finances. Hal Price didn’t leave enough money for Don to live out his last days in a home. Hal Price and his wife Cyndi Price have completely taken over. They both get paid full time salaries by the church. They have no counseling degrees yet still actively counsel church members. Their relationship is controversial due to the fact Cyndi (Cynthia) Ness & Hal Price relationship started with an affair which started as a spiritual connection. This whole situation is extremely corrupt and tragic.
I was in church the night of the first “moving of the Spirit” manifested in the evening service At CCBTC. I was 22 at the time and in my second year of Bible College. The way this move was introduced to the church was by allowing someone to testify about an experience that they had at a Vineyard Movement revival meeting. John Wimbers’ organization sponsored the event. As this man began to testify about his experience “the Spirit” began to “move” upon the congregation . Several pockets of people began to cry or laugh and the rest of us looked on in amazement, including the leadership. I remember watching as it spread across the congregation effecting everyone in its’ path. Eventually it “swept” across my section and I felt an incredible sense of safety and comfort. I was so moved that I felt tears coming to my eyes and laughter arising from some where deep inside me. Laughter at the relief I felt and the ridiculousness of the event. The Pastor and church council called a meeting to figure out what to do. They concluded that it was a somewhat unprecedented event, but undoubtably the Spirit was doing something. They looked to the scriptures for guidance and found in the book of acts and church history similar accounts. At the next meeting they announced that they thought it best to “go with the flow” and keep a close eye on things. They did not want any fanaticism at loose in the church. Over the next 6 months the “spirit moved over the church” and many people including myself, experienced life changing benefits. Where things went wrong was that carnality and ego soon entered the picture and things started to get off track and spiral out of control. I left in the summer of 1982. I was one of the fortunate ones… Those experiences “in the spirit” have benefited me throughout my life. I will give credit to the leadership, they tried, really tried to keep things pure. There were just to many skeletons in the closet and unresolved conflicts of soul to stay ahead of the impending storm. They were one of many churches that got caught up in the vineyard movement and ended up shipwrecked.
Here’s to the survivors and victims!
Remember the path of love and the ways of forgiveness.